NPA withdraws murder charges against TV host Xolani Khumalo

• Jeremy van Dyk
• 1 Comments

When Xolani Khumalo, television presenter of Moja Love learned that the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) had provisionally withdrawn the murder charges hanging over him, the relief was palpable. The decision, announced on Monday, 5 October 2025, pauses a legal saga that began with a violent confrontation in Katlehong, a township east of Johannesburg, back in July 2023.

What sparked the case?

The incident unfolded on 22 July 2023 when Khumalo and his crew from the hard‑hitting investigative programme Sizok'thola entered a house suspected of housing a drug operation. According to police reports, they came face‑to‑face with a man identified as Robert "Kicks" Varrie, a self‑styled drug dealer. A heated exchange escalated into a physical struggle; Varrie was struck, later fell unconscious, and died of injuries while receiving emergency care.

Authorities initially charged Khumalo with murder, robbery, and malicious damage to property – a trio of serious offences that sent shockwaves through South Africa’s media landscape. The charges also triggered Khumalo’s immediate dismissal from Moja Love, effectively ending his two‑year run as the show’s outspoken front‑man.

Why the provisional withdrawal matters

The NPA’s move is not a full acquittal. It merely suspends prosecution while investigators re‑examine forensic evidence, CCTV footage, and witness statements that emerged after the original trial preparations. A spokesperson for the NPA told reporters that "new material" required a thorough review before a final decision could be made, hinting at either exculpatory evidence or procedural irregularities in the original charge sheet.

Legal analysts point out that provisional withdrawals are rare in high‑profile murder cases, especially when a public figure is involved. "It signals that the Crown believes there’s a reasonable doubt that needs to be clarified," said Adv. Thandiwe Ndlovu, a criminal law specialist at the University of Pretoria. "If the evidence doesn’t meet the threshold for a successful prosecution, the NPA is obligated to step back and avoid a wrongful conviction."

Public reaction and social media buzz

Within minutes of the announcement, the hashtag #KhumaloFree began trending on X (formerly Twitter), gathering over 120 000 posts. Supporters framed Khumalo as a community hero fighting the drug menace, while critics warned that the show’s confrontational style blurred the line between journalism and vigilantism.

One user, @JohannesburgVoice, wrote, "If the NPA is pulling the plug, maybe they found proof that the ‘dead drug dealer’ was actually an innocent by‑stander. The truth matters more than the headline." Conversely, @LegalWatchSA posted, "Justice must not be delayed for the sake of a TV rating. The investigation must be transparent, no matter who the subject is."

Impact on anti‑drug activism and media ethics

The provisional withdrawal revives a broader debate about the role of investigative TV shows in South Africa’s fight against illicit drugs. Sizok'thola pioneered a style that mixed on‑the‑ground raids with real‑time confrontation, a formula that drew both high viewership and criticism from media watchdogs.

Media commentator Lebo Mthembu argued, "Khumalo’s case is a litmus test for press freedom. If journalists can be prosecuted for stepping into dangerous zones, the industry might self‑censor, leaving communities exposed to unchecked crime."

At the same time, community leaders in Katlehong expressed frustration that the media spectacle might distract from long‑term solutions such as job creation and youth outreach programs. "We need schools and clinics, not just a TV crew with a camera," said local councillor Mandla Dlamini.

What’s next for Khumalo and the NPA?

As the NPA conducts its renewed investigation, Khumalo remains on bail and has hinted at returning to television, albeit with a more measured approach. In a brief statement to reporters, he said, "I’m focused on clearing my name and continuing the fight against drugs, but I’ll respect whatever the legal process decides."

Legal experts expect a formal decision from the NPA by early 2026, either to reinstate the charges or to close the case definitively. Meanwhile, the public will be watching closely, not just for Khumalo’s fate, but for what the outcome says about the balance between aggressive journalism and the rule of law.

Key Facts

• Charges withdrawn: murder charges against Xolani Khumalo (July 2023 incident).
• Location of incident: Katlehong, east of Johannesburg.
• Victim: Robert "Kicks" Varrie.
• Prosecutor: National Prosecuting Authority.
• TV Show: Sizok'thola on Moja Love.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the NPA decide to withdraw the charges?

The NPA said new material surfaced that could affect the strength of the prosecution’s case. They are re‑examining forensic reports, video evidence and witness statements before deciding whether to resume the trial.

What does this mean for Xolani Khumalo’s career?

Khumalo remains on bail and has hinted at a potential return to TV, though likely with a less confrontational format. His reputation will largely depend on the final legal outcome and public perception of his anti‑drug activism.

How are South Africans reacting to the withdrawal?

Social media is split: many fans celebrate the pause as a step toward justice for Khumalo, while legal observers warn against letting media personalities influence the judicial process without full transparency.

What impact does this case have on media coverage of crime?

The episode raises questions about the limits of investigative journalism. It may prompt broadcasters to review safety protocols and legal safeguards when confronting suspected criminals on‑camera.

When can we expect a final decision from the NPA?

Legal analysts predict the NPA will issue a definitive ruling by early 2026, after completing its deeper evidence review and consulting with forensic experts.